Session 8: Consideration of Model Programs
and Community Interventions
Objectives for Session 8:
- Students will conduct a literature search to identify interventions that address at least 2 of the contributing factors for their community health problem.
- Students will identify the criteria on which interventions should be evaluated (see attached Form 8.1 Intervention Summary).
- Students will summarize the results of different interventions.
- Students will list the strengths and weaknesses of identified interventions in the local community context.
- Students will rank interventions based on the ability to respond to important criteria.
- Students will develop an initial set of objectives for 2 proposed community interventions.
- Students will recommend evaluation strategies for the proposed community interventions.
Community Experience
January 15/17 or January 2 to 17, 2008
Student Assignment (before Session 8 Community Experience):
- Review PATCH Chapter 5 and read PATCH Chapter 6.
- Watch the mini-lecture on AIMS demonstrating how to conduct a literature search to find model interventions/programs.
- Read Self Instructional Package on Program Evaluation which is posted on AIMS.
- Go to the library and research different interventions that address the identified community health problem by impacting the identified contributing factors.
- Begin completing Form 8.1 Intervention Summary.
Community Experience Activities (Jan 15/17 or Jan 2 to 17):
Students will:
- Present preliminary recommendations for community interventions to community faculty.
- Provide the community faculty with copies of papers from the scientific literature in which the proposed interventions are described and used.
- Propose objectives for the interventions.
Community faculty will:
- Review issues identified on the Intervention Summary and any others that are appropriate.
- Discuss history of the community with any similar programs.
- Discuss feedback regarding the feasibility of the proposed interventions in the local context.
- Suggest options for evaluation in the local context.
Rootstown Session January 18, 2008
Student Assignment (before Rootstown Session 8):
- Provide the Rootstown faculty with copies of the Intervention Summary and the scientific papers that were provide to the community faculty.
- Begin Form 8.2 Program Evaluation Plan
Rootstown Session Activities (Jan 18, 1-2:00pm):
Rootstown faculty will:
- Review with students the underlying model and the strength of the evidence linking the contributing factors to the health outcome.
- Review the strength and weakness of proposed interventions for implementation in the local community.
- Assist the students in developing both a process and an outcome evaluation with appropriate objectives and data collection methods.
- Assist the students to begin completing Form 8.2 Program Evaluation Plan.
Student Assignment in Order to Complete Written Assignment for Session 8:
- Research any additional programs that your Rootstown or community faculty may have suggested.
- Finalize the Form 8.1 Intervention Summary sheets from the synthesis for at least 2 interventions.
- Rank the interventions in terms of impact and feasibility.
- Finalize Form 8.2 Program Evaluation Plan for 2 interventions.
Written Assignment for Session 8 (Due Jan 28, 5:00pm):
For two potential interventions, provide the following information:
- Completed Form 8.1 CAN Intervention Summary.
- Completed Form 8.2 Program Evaluation Plan.
- Copies of journal articles (links to websites, etc.) describing the model program/intervention that were not previously provided to the Rootstown faculty.
Resources for Session 8:
PATCH, Chapter 5: Developing a comprehensive intervention plan, Chapter 6: Evaluating PATCH.
Mini-lecture on AIMS on conducting a literature review.
Self-Instructional Package on Program Evaluation, posted on AIMS.
CDC Community Guide to Preventive Services. Evidence-based recommendations for programs and policies to promote population health. At: http://www.thecommunityguide.org/
Partnership for Prevention. A national membership organization dedicated to building evidence of sound disease prevention and health promotion policies and practices and advocating their adoption by public and private sectors. At: http://www.prevent.org/
Community Tool Box Develop an Intervention at http://ctb.ku.edu/tools/intervention/outline.jsp
NEOUCOM databases at http://www.neoucom.edu/audience/library/resources/eresources
The Guide to Community Preventive Services, Evidence based recommendations for programs and policies to promote population health at http://www.TheCommunityGuide.org/
NEOUCOM reference librarians.
R. H. Fletcher & S. W. Fletcher: Chapter 9 Prevention, Chapter 11 Cause, Chapter 12 Systematic Reviews
Session 8: Form 1
Community Assessment Notebook Intervention Summary
Strengths/ Weaknesses of Program Choices
Strategy:________________________________________________________
|
Strength of the evidence supporting the ability of the intervention to impact the contributing factor (from the literature)
|
|
|
Gaps in current programs
|
|
|
Potential for community partnerships
|
|
|
Barriers to proposed intervention
|
|
|
Feasibility of the proposed intervention
|
|
|
Generalizability to the current population
|
|
|
Acceptability to clients
|
|
|
Funding potential
|
|
|
Sustainability
|
|
|
Scope
|
|
|
Duration
|
|
|
Evaluability
|
|
|
Other factors
|
|
Session 8: Form 2
Program Evaluation Plan
|
What is the Outcome Objective?
|
|
|
What are the Impact Objectives?
|
|
|
How might the objectives be measured?
|
|
|
What are the options for data collection? Who, what, when and how?
|
|
|
Strengths or limitations of data?
|
|
|
What process measures could be obtained?
|
|
|